[Noisebridge-discuss] anti-anonymity proposal take 2

Al Sweigart asweigart at gmail.com
Wed Mar 12 16:38:17 UTC 2014


I think this problem is already solved: people can become members under a
pseudonym.

Further, I don't see what abuse can be done by the officers maintaining a
list. It's in our bylaws that members can request a current member list.
On Mar 12, 2014 12:30 AM, "Naomi Most" <pnaomi at gmail.com> wrote:

> What problem are you trying to solve?
>
>
> On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 11:40 PM,  <bfb at riseup.net> wrote:
> > A proposal to publish the membership list on the noisebridge/bureaucracy
> > repository[1] was discussed at the Tuesday meeting tonight. I asked that
> > it be tabled, recalling a thread[2] from November on this list. Does
> > anyone have any more feedback? Amendments to the proposal?
> >
> > I have mixed feelings. 1) Transparency allows a fair decision making
> > process. Anonymous participation in a consensus decision making process
> > could be abused. 2) A list that is only available to officers of
> > Noisebridge as the final source of truth can also be abused. 3) I will
> not
> > question anyone's need for privacy, and Noisebridge should go to lengths
> > to support member's articulating the need for privacy.
> >
> > I do not feel that the status quo has been abused, only that the
> potential
> > exists. Is the wiki category solution sufficient? Does publishing a list
> > on github compromise privacy in a way that the Noisebridge wiki does not?
> >
> > -Kevin
> >
> > [1] https://github.com/noisebridge/bureaucracy/issues/3
> > [2]
> >
> https://noisebridge.net/pipermail/noisebridge-discuss/2013-November/040368.html
> >
> > -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
> > Version: GnuPG v1
> >
> > owF1VHtMVXUc5yEqpyTKV4XJz6UJBPcCN5kBcsVcRmhugmleUc7jd+/9yXlxfr9z
> > r9cszYb5mgNdDnWiYUa50Nac2RihDrN85SMXKaBddaZOI8yWurLvuQcctfnH2X47
> > v+/j8/h+f9WDYqO46HkxOQW36mP16MZ+qUKsQn0lKHpCIdINTdcoLyOmId0UZEL9
> > iPkxUrAiYIP6iY7gH0OaGvmtaoRiwSCSDzsF08C8KRq8GEIGhiqEaUbIk1WGgjxF
> > EqGiSSmWEM8iqaUmphIfgsqYEdUHDVXi8zMHKkI8rYA45odIwpCAEeMFGUvpUFbk
> > ZdmK5uEa2kme7DLkNTQFvaEFIhBtZIRGYDrQZA1TxKshTcXIzwewdUaKZmDkxVgS
> > eLHCjQoVrErwMWqxtrD1quDmuCI7TSELARLkWN2pA2WlolKDV6nOG1gFwgBLC0In
> > 5OWJgSQsEkoAicJXWGihnogppBWqmhpSNJMiSGREJDrPrDiiQqqoqRSrFC4fkQ8R
> > pixZgvCCCVI6UHYqKrQNsdWiQF8GNAGeyJZmFiHN6yUieAcHUOmhX6ByhKuXqGA3
> > 1UxDxFYIM0zmRyIPiGSq9W3mSgVvgkSWwXaGKsG/CHZb3bEUqdiSSDMALgnAFKTD
> > lfSfltQfIeDTLFwyVn3MH9GcmrquGaxnyqBURBxT5u3JsAbtf7UdljOSFkFiuWLz
> > tyIp4xlIWGlq4BwF/FjtYZBui/MwUtcYmE6APV4IEoI9RbYkQVJBQAGGfTDAII1s
> > RohS01KSQI7bnqueBbHnsXctfIT5TQGsUsA1Bbj3QrZNDvJ9EPTVJtJUssoCJxi8
> > jGIcICrHWQvkZ0ynuU6nXdsBtZ2P2DwnoRSMcbo4azN68/oEO1TMnDrRsaHAjPS9
> > yehZUWd2ZpYro3efnJkvZbpyxjv8TJG5lTEj+kVFc1H942Ks5yKKi0/sfUfKWxOj
> > 6lv/XnUz94+h35YN9jUkHumatOmvOYtaLuStW1XefGZQ6Zi09lrvO2XOzj0n61zR
> > hc1T6g937Pgwq+mmceC1rZOfbHr9sQ1zj58qad85q6Dy3o32ztjvPxAvNGbIbs8K
> > 3+KaIwmewf255Ny5nw+PCud8emnf02duf9VdlfaiZ+nI5rE/e2e2uhclL9zS+Ezr
> > tqSBH4V+yBt4ZczUA20J1VfbYkaUfjd9Bbc0pfR+0e7rRafCu2L33zn3+16lMWkj
> > t9XdNafrS1Gfveqt49OW/9gwcsvsDjHt8pr3y1uS/jFLqhIvdiytc5mXN83YvkMM
> > 3l0/uvLNw3HqbykpwybVBrU44e3a+Jrc/TcG7T0f+KW44d68Q/rVoePHTKwfuuH6
> > KaWh05NzbMj6avcntV0J+UJTTeF7yctowRNHdkx5/NrOvK3tbS84klu/WFnT37k6
> > YcKSlvBP744MuSfefW7UZyyNW9zxVFVGCuqeULDNp5DNd9ZsPxt/5c+j2RcXn24N
> > qwcTmh6cu73t2O24mQvWxk9K1/PmL6p8ueNE3ehA3dklad0PTi+79nzSpVsf78sf
> > MO6VXzNrmk8ucK2tq56+K7mxpG1GcffY87tfnZu7Yt6znU1kQPji6mnTW8KHtiv3
> > D5TvnD1sftW9b1IuSJtTDxoxR4fdapk1o/3rjvv54zaOGh7OXzekovjM+NTOtfKo
> > qXrFnrTJ/U488AgJ/wI=
> > =wowJ
> > -----END PGP MESSAGE-----
> >
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > Noisebridge-discuss mailing list
> > Noisebridge-discuss at lists.noisebridge.net
> > https://www.noisebridge.net/mailman/listinfo/noisebridge-discuss
>
>
>
> --
> Naomi Theora Most
> naomi at nthmost.com
> +1-415-728-7490
>
> skype: nthmost
>
> http://twitter.com/nthmost
> _______________________________________________
> Noisebridge-discuss mailing list
> Noisebridge-discuss at lists.noisebridge.net
> https://www.noisebridge.net/mailman/listinfo/noisebridge-discuss
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.noisebridge.net/pipermail/noisebridge-discuss/attachments/20140312/ece64101/attachment-0003.html>


More information about the Noisebridge-discuss mailing list