[Noisebridge-discuss] on allowing anonymous editing on the wiki
Johny Radio
johnyradio at gmail.com
Tue May 20 01:37:44 UTC 2014
(sorry Casey and Danny for breaking the thread, this did not go into my
mail client so i had to paste from the archive)
Re: Naomi's post:
https://www.noisebridge.net/pipermail/noisebridge-discuss/2014-May/044631.html
Naomi wrote: >>I am struggling to understand -- in this era of Tor nodes
being used to shield anonymous edits from punishment /anyway/ -- how
it's useful or necessary to allow "anonymous" -- meaning, IP-identified
-- editing to our pages.
J: Not useful. It's easy to get a new IP address: Tor, public libraries,
etc.
Naomi wrote: I'm looking for some arguments and perspectives on why
anonymous editing of our most important, public-facing pages should or
shouldn't be allowed.
J: in reply:
Gregory Dillon gregorydillon at gmail.com wrote: The analogy I raise is
to a free speech scheme -- designated no protest areas, and free speech
areas.
J: +1. Most trolling is NOT legitimate political protest, it's just
harassment and vandalism. I think there are more efficient, less
disruptive ways to accomodate anonymous political protest than giving
anonymous trolls free reign on the homepage or userpages. A real hacker
does not need Noisebridge to allow anonymous edits. Even if it's locked
down, a real hacker would figure out how to hack into the thing:
maestro maestro415 at gmail.com, Tue Feb 18 08:18:59 UTC 2014:
Fapfapfaping all over a wiki thats openly editable? Ooh. That really
instills awe.
Naomi, I read the article you recommended on Wicked Problems. The
article describes problems that seem impossible to resolve due to a
fundamental contradiction. Please unpack: what is the contradiction you
see, Naomi? I suggest you read the section called "Strategies", in which
the issue is solved through community collaboration, not "the admins
decide" or "the Board decides" or "Naomi decides".
htttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_problem
More information about the Noisebridge-discuss
mailing list