[Noisebridge-discuss] asked james to leave

Jake jake at spaz.org
Thu Jun 20 22:48:33 UTC 2013

A year and a half ago in the height of occupy (and the influx of troubles 
noisebridge had as a result) I got into an argument with James when I was 
saying that people are responsible for who they allow into noisebridge. 
He loudly took the position that he was not responsible for anything, and 
simply talked over me in any discussion.  He did eventually come to a 
meeting, and i think he was told that his attitude was wrong and 

on a similar note, the other night I was at noisebridge late, when the 
street people come "home", and Pirate Mike arrived.  Upon seeing his 
friends, he said "hey guys, i had a great idea.  Noisebridge is supposed 
to be about hacking.  We occupy, so we should hack occupation by occupying 

I can't say i got the words exactly right but that's as close to a quote 
as i can get.  I think it explains a lot about what's going on.

I think that it's reasonable to expect homeless people to do whatever they 
can to have noisebridge as a place to spend the night, a place to eat and 
cook food, and a place to pull cash out of the donation and t-shirt money 
box.  You or I would probably do the same thing in their situation.

So i think it's reasonable for hackers trying to have a nice hackerspace 
to use basic minimal standards for entry, like being able to convince a 
person who is involved enough to have their own code, to let you in.

if you're not willing to do anything to keep these people out, i don't see 
the point in complaining about their behavior.  They are just doing what 
is reasonable for their needs.  If we don't do the same, whose fault is 


leif wrote:
> I think James epitomizes the truism that by including some people we are
> actually exlcuding others. I hope we don't need to spend too much time
> discussing him at the meeting.

Update on James: When I arrived at Noisebridge a little while ago, he
was outside. I asked if he was coming from or going to Noisebridge, or
just hanging out outside. He said he was just standing on the sidewalk,
and didn't want to talk to me, and said I should expect to be served
with a lawsuit for defamation of character. He also reiterated that he
will be at the Tuesday meeting.


More information about the Noisebridge-discuss mailing list